Sunday, March 13, 2011

Jesus, the Bible, and Education


As Christians throughout the world observe this season of Lent, I will be refocusing my blog on the life of Jesus. Jesus was a teacher. Christians have always believed he was more than just a teacher, but certainly not less.  He instructed a group of 12 disciples for 3 years before his death and resurrection, and even after his resurrection, he went out of his way to teach and open the eyes of his followers who were bewildered at the turn of events that culminated in Jesus’ crucifixion (Lk. 24:25).  Because Jesus was both Lord and Rabbi, it is worthwhile to examine how Jesus educated his followers. 

When turning to the gospels, the first thing that we must mention is that all of Jesus’ teaching, and really his whole life, was Word-centered. The Bible’s narrative, beginning with the books of the law, and stretching into the prophets and the “writings,” form the background for his entire ministry.  When I  read the New Testament for the first time, it was clear that I was starting in the middle of a story.  For example, in the first chapter of John’s gospel, John the Baptist is asked if he is Elijah or “the Prophet.” Without an understanding of biblical prophecy, this is hard to understand. Also, in Mark’s first chapter, Jesus breaks onto the scene and announces, “the kingdom of God has come near. Repent and believe the good news.” Without the Psalms, this announcement is tough to grasp.  Jesus’ life was a fulfillment of the Word.  He literally lives in the narrative of the Scriptures.

As a boy, Jesus’ was immersed in the Scriptures, as all young Jewish boys would have been.  His father Joseph, a carpenter or possibly a stone-worker, would have taught his son the family trade, and educated his child in the Hebrew Scriptures from the first moments he could speak.   Memorizing entire books of the law would not have been uncommon. And we know that when Jesus was 12, he was debating and discussing interpretation of the law with the best religious scholars of his day.  When he launched his public ministry as an adult, nearly everything he did was either a fulfillment of Scripture or a teaching of Scripture. His reverence for the Hebrew Bible was unparalleled (Matt 5:18), and the gospels are filled with his engaging with the scribes and Pharisees about interpretation of the law (Matt 12:1-13).  He referenced Scripture tacitly in his teachings (Matt 12:39-42), and he quoted it often and with exactitude (Matt 13:11-15).  When he was on the cross, at the darkest point of his life, Scripture was on his tongue (Lk 23:46, Mk. 15:33). And when he rose from the dead, he gave a Bible lesson to his followers on the road to Emmaus (Lk 24:27). Jesus’ entire life, ministry, death, and resurrection were filled with Scripture. God’s Word came out of his pores.

Jesus was clearly a teacher of Scripture. To think that he could, in any way, rightly instruct his followers in what we would call today a “secular” fashion, is a contradiction.  Our categories today call religion a personal value that belongs in the home and the church, but not in public discourse, and certainly not in a public school or university.  Although this will have to be a topic for another posting, Jesus clearly did not believe that “religion cannot be known. It’s just a matter of personal opinion.” He centered all that he was on the divine revelation of God that claims not just to be a handbook for living, but instead, as Lesslie Newbigin points out, “universal history.” It reveals God’s eternal purposes for both the people of Israel and all the world’s gentiles.   Because the Bible is the best source on how things really are, it was the core of Jesus’ thought and pedagogy.

Today, the Bible is taught in church, in the family, and in religious schools, but I have never seen anybody teach Scripture on CNN or MSNBC.  And it is certainly not taught as being true in our schools. (Some public schools teach the Bible alongside of other holy books. But such teaching assumes a morally and religiously pluralistic worldview which has its roots in the Enlightenment, not in the Hebrew and Christian Scriptures).   But the life accounts of Jesus make one thing abundantly clear: Scripture was the center point of Jesus’ educational program.  If Scripture is not the center point of our own teaching, whether we inhabit public or private schools, Christians must ask where we have gone wrong.

In the United States, movements to hang the ten commandments in city hall or allow students to pray in public school are met with fierce criticism.  Many are deathly afraid of a regress to an imperceptible “dark age” of religiosity in the US.  They say it violates the first amendment (which, to my untrained eye, doesn’t seem to make sense. Compelling religious adherence in a school and openly teaching the Bible’s truths in a school seem to be different animals). Given, those who are teachers in the public sphere will face this difficult battle.  But if we step back from current political battles, and take a look at Jesus’ own life and teachings, we cannot ignore the Scriptures as a part of all student’s courses of study. If God’s purposes for humanity are universal, then God’s word also must be universally taught.

Thursday, March 10, 2011

John Locke's Thoughts Concerning Education

Before the industrial revolution, it was men, not women, who were primarily in charge of the education of young children. In the days before men took off to work in the factory, they often had a trade and a family business conducted out of the house.  Thus, they were often in charge of the formal instruction of their children.  It’s interesting that before the industrial revolution, there are very few books about education written by women. Instead it was men who took up the task of teaching children and planning for their education.  One of these classic books on education, which is nearly totally forgotten in our own day, is John Locke’s Some Thoughts Concerning Education.

The book is a masterwork by a first-rate mind on the holistic education of the young. In his letter of dedication he writes, “The well educating of their children is so much the duty and concern of parents, and the welfare and prosperity of the nation so much depends on it, that I would have every one lay it seriously to heart; and after having well examin’d and distinguish’d what fancy, custom, or reason advises in the case, set his helping hand to promote every where that training up of youth, with regard their several conditions, which is the easiest, shortest, and likeliest to produce virtuous, useful, and able men in their distinct callings…”

Although I will often return to Some Thoughts Concerning Education on this blog, let me make a few introductory remarks about the above quotation.  First, education is the job of parents. And it ought to be the “duty and concern” of every parent to consider carefully their children’s education. In our day, however, far too many parents (I’ve seen this in my line of work), don’t think intentionally about their children’s education. They are simply shipped off to the closest public school for kindergarten. But if “all the men we meet with, nine parts of ten are what they are, good or evil, useful or not, by their education,” then this topic ought to occupy a central role for families with children.  Whether they decide on public, private, Christian, or home school, the decision must be done intentionally—and for good reason.

Second, Locke recommends that “every one lay it seriously to heart.”  I know I’m not qualified to comment on the state of education, but in 21st century America, there are not enough scholars and leaders who are really willing to “lay it seriously to heart.” In America, new teachers are, on average, the bottom third of college graduates (in stark contrast to Singapore, whereby only the top third are accepted as new teachers.)  And for some reason, a good many text books on education in our modern world are lengthy treatises on educational psychology.  Very few of the country’s best scholar’s are doing as Locke did – spending diligent energy on examining the roots, methods, and content of education for our modern world.  On university campuses, when it is learned that an individual got his or her doctorate in education, it is often looked upon with disdain as not a truly “academic” doctorate.  It was not always so.

Third, and finally, Locke believes that his task in the book was to find “which is the easiest, shortest, and likeliest [way] to produce virtuous, useful, and able men in their distinct callings…” What a contrast to our state standards today!  First, the purpose is not “college readiness” or higher test scores, but virtue. In postmodern America, most authorities in public education are interested in producing students of character, but are reticent to say which virtues are worth pursuing, if any, and how one might build a curriculum for virtue. And second, competent people who are living out their “calling” is the goal of his volume.  Who talks of calling within public discourse but those “odd religious people”?  Since calling assumes a Caller, Locke’s words become difficult to understand for many secular people in a religiously and morally pluralistic world.

Locke’s volume is clear, comprehensive, and a gem of a guide to the education of the young. Although our scientific understandings would now differ with him on various points, there is much to be learned from pondering this great English philosopher’s words on education.  If you can find it online from some collector, pick it up this week. It won’t disappoint.  

Sunday, March 6, 2011

Waiting for Superman: Tenure, Unions and a Real Superhero

Anybody with even a cursory interest in the 57 million children in America's public school system should see Waiting for Superman.  Davis Guggenheim's documentary on failing American public schools succeeds on many levels. First, it's a helpful overview to how the school system works.  The complexities of federal, state and local power in public schools are made clear, and quirks like the tenure system in K-12 education are brought to light.  Second, it succeeds emotionally.  Following the stories of five families from low income areas, and their struggles to provide a decent education for their aspiring children, had my wife and I at the edge of our seats at the conclusion of the movie. Third, it succeeds as polemic.  The film is obviously biased against teacher's unions and in favor of charter schools and other public school alternatives.  But it is biased with good reason.  And this is the point of this posting: introducing competition, even mild competition, to the school system will reap great benefits for those on the lower quarter of the social totem pole.
Let's start with the tenure system.  Tenure was introduced into the university system to protect professors with politically unpopular opinions from being fired.  It started as a free speech issue.  But the practice has been adopted into the K-12 system.  Teachers who can still walk and breath (walking is optional), after 3 years get tenure.  Although some school districts have quality evaluation processes during this period, for the majority this means that some terrible teachers get secure jobs.  The film showed a scene of the "rubber room" in New York City, where dozens of teachers are paid to sit, read the newspaper, sleep and not teach because they're protected in their job.  This apparently costs $100 million per year.  And yet they can't be fired.  The film also claims that if only the bottom 1/5 of teachers in the US were fired and replaced by only average teachers, our national test scores would reach those of Finland, more than a dozen places higher on international exam scores.  Waiting for Superman shows the struggles that administrators like Geoffry Canada and Michelle Rhee faced when trying to fire bad teachers, but were unable to because of the protection unions had given to tenured teachers.  Rhee comments that tenure helps adults, but hurts the kids.
Second, the film takes a healthy crack at teacher's unions.  As the protectorate of the bad and the good teachers, unions have prevented comprehensive education reform by disallowing poor teachers to be fired without an absurd 24 step process to remove the offending pedagogue.  Through recruiting young unsuspecting teachers, often through heavy handed guilt trips in the first 2 years of a teacher's career (my wife received several of these), many are enrolled into paying dues to the union.  Surely, some unions have had a good purpose.  And there are obviously good teachers in public schools (my wife, my sister, and my mother are good examples). But with state budgets across the country being squeezed, the unions find themselves under fire.  Just look at the battle in Wisconsin.  Times are changing.
Third, the film is quite blatantly pro-charter school.  The film culminates with a dramatic scene of five kids who are desperately hoping to have their numbers drawn to be enrolled in a high-performing charter school.  Knowing that this kid's future is in many ways determined by his or her school choice leaves the movie-goer with a palpable desire to see the child get in.  All but two don't get in, and are forced to go back to their "drop-out factory" schools.  Our hearts sink.
          The rise in charter schools in the past decade, especially prominent movements like KIPP, is notable.  They are introducing competition into the public school system.  They must perform, or they lose their charter, and thus their funding.  This pressure often times produces results.  Even though various studies have shown that many charter schools are no better than their public counterparts, the presence of significant freedom from public regulation in exchange for results has had tremendously positive impacts.  The film highlights many charter schools, like Geoffrey Canada's Harlem Success Academy, that are having superb results in the most difficult socio-economic circumstances.  As I drove home last week, I saw an open house banner at Homestead Elementary, a public school by my house, advertising "Now Enrolling."  Charter schools are clearly having an effect.

So, what's the solution?  How do we get better schools?  The movies suggests, by way of the high performing schools highlighted, that the answer lies in teacher accountability, longer hours, and higher standards.  Longer school hours mean more opportunities for learning, and high standards mean they won't accept some kids shooting for just okay.  But the real key, as I've mentioned earlier in my blog, is great teachers.  School districts and individual schools, whether they be public or private, with systems for rewarding excellent teachers and getting rid of bad teachers are the most important elements in student success.  Administrators would be wise to ignore about half of their current responsibilities and find ways to hold teacher's accountable to the highest standards of student success.
Let me finish with this idea: the title "Waiting for Superman" introduces a hidden issue, one not addressed by the film.  Guggenheim mentions that students are waiting for a superman who will come to save them from their plight.  The film concludes, however, that the superman is really "you" who must take action in education reform in America.  As inspiring as this is, it hits a certain chord with secular minded people trying to "change the world."  Education, it is thought, is the key to bringing about justice, equality, and even a version of "salvation" to the world.  But education can't do it.  Poor children stuck in bad schools are indeed waiting for a Superman; they are waiting for a Savior.  Education has become the quintessential secular moralist's cause of our generation.  It's no coincidence that 10% of Ivy League graduates applied for Teach for America last year.  But education alone cannot bring about the superhero results we hope for.  Only a true Savior can do that.
The lessons of Waiting for Superman ought to be considered by all those making decisions about education in America.  The plight of poor children in under-performing schools, the silliness of the K-12 tenure system, and the counter-productive effect of many teacher's unions ought to cause the people of the Kingdom of God to ask the question, How shall we build a better educational system for tomorrow?  But at the same time, let us not forget that Superman has come, and He gives real, enduring hope to all people, literate and illiterate alike.  May this hope shape an ethic of educational change for the sake of the 57 million children with pencil in hand, ready to take hold of a better life.

Sunday, February 20, 2011

The Joyful Pursuit

During my second year of seminary, I launched a book group that would later be named (by an eccentric bartender named Paul) The Scholar's Table. Our purpose was simple: gather together every two weeks at a pub and discuss history's greatest books.  To date, we have read books as diverse as Plato's Republic and Milton's Paradise Lost to Orwell's 1984 and Ralph Ellison's Invisible Man. Why do such a thing?  Well, I stumbled upon an old year-end note to my fellow member's of The Scholar's Table, and I thought I'd share it with you here.  It gives a glimpse at my love of learning and my continuing interest in education.  Happy reading...

Dear Scholar’s Table,

From Twain and Milton to Thoreau and Tolstoy, from Barnes’ sleeping outside for a year’s supply of chicken sandwiches to the announcement of a new little Barber, 2009 was a year to remember.

I want to thank each of you individually, Barnes, Durkin, Shinnick, Barber, Farmer, and Kell, for a year filled with bright conversations and deep friendships.  Yet I mostly want to thank you for being willing to journey alongside me as we explore the great books of history.  As I grow a year older, it seems to me that the unrestrained pursuit of wisdom is of central importance to who we become as leaders, as fathers, as husbands, and as men.  And this is why.

First, as I’ve graduated from school and entered the work force and the family life, I find myself confused as ever.  As I try to plan out my workweek, I often wonder, what should I spend my week doing?  What is of most importance, and what can be ignored?  And as I sit down at the dinner table and see my daughter throw string cheese and peas across the room, I ask myself, Now what should I do about this? Shall I raise my voice, shake my finger, or throw the peas back at her?  And as I interact with people from another culture regularly, I ask myself, Why is it that after all this time I still have racist attitudes toward Hispanics? How could this really be? 

Everywhere I turn in life, I seek out answers that I can’t simply conjure from thin air.  I need the wisdom of those who have gone before me.  Pursuing truth and wisdom from some of the most able hearts and minds of history sheds light on my path.  As my own ignorance and confusion fogs my view, the light of truth opens new possibilities.  The great authors, of whom He is the greatest, bring not necessarily more intelligence, but more clarity.  True education brings not more complexity, but ultimately more clarity.  Those who pursue wisdom in all areas of life, not just biblical studies, will emerge as capable leaders, fathers, husbands, and men.

Second, people are looking to us for answers.  Our children, our wives, our middle schoolers, our co-workers—they need us to be “shepherds after my own heart who will lead with knowledge and understanding.”  But what so often happens is that we “graduate” and believe that our education is over!  Just when we need to be learning most voraciously, we often times turn to what’s easy instead of what’s right.  After school, the freedom to cut corners is always before us.  But it is just then that people will be looking up to us the most, and need us to study, learn, and to know the wisdom of our ancestors and so provide a wise course for the future.  Fellas, our education never ends!  As corny as I thought learning contracts were, self-directed, life-long learning is a necessity.  It we don’t set the course, others will set it for us.

I will share a secret with you.  What you do with your leisure time determines who you will become. That one I pulled from a lecture by Mortimer Adler---and he’s absolutely right.  It is not primarily your degrees, your grades, your culture or your family background (Kell can argue that one), that determines who you will become.  It is how you spend your free time when nobody’s looking.   This one of the most important factors in determining who you will become.  It’s odd to think that Saturday afternoons set the course of our lives.  But truly, if you long to seek wisdom when nobody’s looking, then that’s what you will become.

Third, and finally, I would argue that the pursuit of wisdom is not only of central importance, but it is a great joy.  I must confess that when I’m reading a book and I come across a line or a scene that permanently shapes the way I think, I completely geek out.  For me, discovering a deep truth in a dusty book that my peers have long thought “outdated” gives me the same pleasure that Sir Edmund Hillary must have got from mountain climbing or Jacques Cousteau from scuba diving.  It is coming to a cool sunrise and knowing deeply that the world is beautiful.  Beauty.  Perhaps that is my real motivation for learning.  God’s world is filled with wonder and beauty.

Friends, I thank you deeply for journeying alongside me.  And who knows what the next year will bring.  A move east, more children, graduation, jobs…the changes will be rapid.  Who will we choose as companions for our travels?  I implore you, even after seminary, choose first the men of God in the Scriptures.  And second, choose not what is most popular, and surely not what is easiest, but choose the path less traveled.  Choose to do hard things.  Choose the wisest guides of human history as your peers.  Keep searching for wisdom through 2010 and into the blazing mid-day of your lives.

Blessings, my brothers, rejoice this Christmas in the Wisdom of God made flesh.

Jeff Haanen

“Get wisdom.  Though it costs you all you have, get understanding.”
-King Solomon

Friday, February 18, 2011

Three Cups of Tea

I just finished listening to an interesting book entitled Three Cups of Tea. The book chronicles the story of Greg Mortenson, a mountaineer from Montana who builds schools, especially for girls, across Afghanistan and Pakistan.  In 1992, Mortenson's sister died of an epileptic attack. To honor his sister, he climbed Pakistan's K2, the world's second highest mountain.  While nearly dying in the attempt, he stumbled upon a small village called Korphe. The kindness of the villagers spurred him to make a promise: he would return to build a school.  Three years later, and wild twists ranging from fund raising in the US and negotiating prices for building materials in Pakistan, Mortenson built his school. 

A dying scientist heard of Greg's work and gave him enough money to endow the Central Asia Institute (CAI). After decades of work, today the CAI has built hundreds of schools. According to the website:
As of 2011, Mortenson has established or significantly supports 171 schools in rural and often volatile regions of Pakistan and Afghanistan, which provide education to over 68,000 children, including 54,000 girls, where few education opportunities existed before.
The book matters, on many levels. First, his crusade to "fight terror with books" has hit a nerve among peace-loving Americans in the age of "The War on Terror."  Second, education is tremendously powerful (as are all institutionalized mediums for exchanging ideas. For example, in early 2000, wealthy Saudi donors began investing millions in building wahabi madrassas.  A madrassa is an Islamic theological school, and wahabism is an extremist version of Islam. In 2001, the World Bank did a study on these madrassas.  Nearly 20,000 madrassas were educating 2 million pakistani children, 80,000 of whom, the World Bank estimates, became Taliban fighters.  What many desperate children learned in these schools was directly connected to the burning buildings of 9/11.  Education matters.

Mortenson is being hailed as a national hero--he is even up for the Nobel Peace Prize this year.  And Mortenson ought to be hailed for the many great things he has done.

However, he is the quintessential secular hero. He is essentially agnostic, and he built schools that provided a moderate Muslim education.  Noble, yes. But the story of Three Cups of Tea reminded me of how odd Christians are in the world.  Secular people believe that the problem is "outside themselves," thus seeking solutions in "the world", such as building schools. But Christians believe that the essential problem is "inside ourselves"--sin--and the solution is a Savior. 

In my opinion, Mortenson is genuinely a noble man. But there is a something--or Someone--missing at his core.  He has inspired me to lift up my eyes to the hills, and use education as a tool to improve the lives of many.  But at the top of the hill, there is a God who calls out from Zion to all those who are hungry, thirsty, and in need.  Education can change lives, but the Gospel can change the world.  As Milton has said, the end or learning is to repair the ruins of our first parents. Their ruin was not ignorance, but sin.  Ignorance is a plague, but sin is at its center. Schools can be an eternal influence in as much as they bear the Name.

Sunday, February 13, 2011

K-12 Budget Cuts in Colorado

The Denver Post ran a story today entitled "Deep education cuts loom." The subtitle read "The state could slash up to $450 million from K-12 and higher ed."  As Governor Hickenlooper faces a $1 billion budget shortfall, public education officials are predicting major changes to K-12 education in Colorado.  9 News last night guessed that up to 6,500 teachers may be laid off.

Why not cut another place of the budget?  That's tough considering the financial commitments of the state of Colorado.  The $7 billion general operating fund is 97 percent committed to just five areas: K-12 education, health care for the poor, human services, prisons and higher education. Levels of spending on health care, human services and prisons are, to some degree, protected by federal law. The only thing left to cut is education.

There is fear for many teachers and school officials in the days before Hickenlooper's big announcement this coming Tuesday.  But what are parents thinking right now? As pressured public schools already face increasing class sizes and cut funding for programs, parents eager to give their children a quality education will start looking elsewhere.  My guess is that many concerned parents will start exploring options in charter schools and, increasingly, private schools.

What is a Christian to do about this?  For the myriad of devoted Christians within the public school system, they will need to do more with less, a common challenge for all those in both the public and private sectors who faced daunting times in this past recession.  For those within the Christian school movement, this could be an opportunity.  Dissatisfaction with public schools usually means increasing numbers for private schools.  However, administrators and leaders within the Christian school movement would be wise to "mourn with those who mourn."  Christian schools have the curricular liberty to build service events into their school days. Many of these service events and initiatives should focus their efforts on public schools, and scores of students in them whom God so loves.

Sunday, February 6, 2011

Teacher Accountability

As I've noted in previous posts, good teachers are the key to good schools.  Budgets, curriculum, facilities--all take a second place to excellent teaching.  A recent article in The Economist entitled "Lessons learned" gave an overview of recent movements set on improving teacher quality.  In 2009, Hillsborough County, Florida, won a grant from the Gates Foundation to transform the way it evaluates, develops and rewards its teachers. The Superintendent Mary Ellen Elia, while being fair to unions, has launched a method of evaluating teachers. An extended quote:
Teachers will be judged on their pupils’ progress, as well as evaluations by a principal and by a peer. Teachers with high ratings, based on three years of data, will have higher salaries. Bad teachers will see their salaries shrink. A struggling teacher will receive further training. If he continues to be ineffective, Mrs Elia will act to remove him.
This particular case is worth reflection.   The elements of reforming poor and mediocre teachers, and thus poor and mediocre schools, are all here.  Teachers are judged on three things: pupil's progress (the accomplishment of predetermined objectives through test scores), evaluations by a principal and evaluations by a peer.  When these three elements are present, enough information over a 3 year period helps determine whether a teacher gets a salary increase or should be sent to remedial training, or fired.

Having been the husband, brother, and son of public school teachers my whole life, I've heard stories of grossly ineffective accountability for teachers. Great teachers go unnoticed but do it "for the love of teaching," whereas ineffective teachers stay put or bounce around the district and never leave because of tenure.

Again, I'm an amateur on the subject, but teacher accountability seems to me the central element in building a successful school.  The administrator's central role must be to hire great teachers, and then to give sufficient accountability to ensure that great teaching is the norm in any school. Budgets, text books, problem cases--all of these must take a back seat to finding and encouraging great teachers.  Those who want to leave an indelible mark on a school district or a school would be wise to follow Mrs Elia's example.